How to Vet a Property Manager Before You Buy a Poconos Airbnb

If you’re buying an Airbnb in the Poconos, your property manager will determine more than just guest check-ins.

The right manager can protect your permit, your reviews, and your net income. The wrong one can cost you thousands in refunds, township violations, and lost bookings.

At Investment Real Estate of the Poconos, we guide buyers through the vetting process before they close. Here’s how to evaluate a property manager, and why it matters so much in Monroe County.

Verify They’re Local to the Poconos, Not Just Statewide

The Poconos isn’t like other Airbnb markets. Between township-specific permit rules, seasonal weather, and HOA restrictions, you need a team that lives and works here.

Questions to ask:

• How close is your office to the property?

• How quickly can you respond to a guest lockout or burst pipe?

• Which townships and HOAs do you actively manage in?

  
  

Jeremiah’s Take: We also own Galvanized Management and we’ve seen remote managers promise “coverage” but fail township inspections because they didn’t understand Monroe County requirements. Boots on the ground matter here.

Ask If They Handle Permitting and Compliance

In Monroe County, your Airbnb permit doesn’t transfer automatically when you buy. The new owner has to apply, pass inspections, and get on the township’s radar.

Ask your manager:

• Do you assist with township Airbnb permit applications and renewals?

• Will you coordinate inspections and required upgrades?

• Do you track HOA and township regulation changes?

  
  

Jeremiah’s Take: A manager who doesn’t handle compliance will leave you scrambling. We’ve seen new owners delayed for months because their manager didn’t have a plan for permitting.

Dig Into Their Cleaning and Maintenance Model

The #1 reason Poconos Airbnbs get bad reviews? Cleaning and maintenance.

Ask:

• Do you use in-house cleaners or subcontract?

• How do you track quality and missed turnovers?

• Can you handle snow removal, trash, and septic emergencies?

  
  

Jeremiah’s Take: If they don’t have teams on call in Tobyhanna, Tunkhannock, Coolbaugh, or Penn Forest, they can’t get to your property fast enough in a snowstorm or power outage.

Understand What’s Included vs. Extra

Low management fees (20% or less) often hide “coordination” charges for things you thought were covered.

Ask to see a full list of:

• Cleaning fees

• Vendor markups

• Trash, lawn, and snow service

• Emergency callouts

• Marketing fees

  
  

Jeremiah’s Take: A 25% all-inclusive manager can net you more than a “cheaper” manager who nickel-and-dimes you and doesn’t optimize your calendar.

Check Their Track Record With Reviews and Bookings

Your manager’s performance will directly affect:

• Your average nightly rate

• Your occupancy

• Your guest reviews

  
  

Ask:

• How many properties do you manage in my township?

• What’s your average Airbnb rating across your portfolio?

• Do you use dynamic pricing?

  
  

Jeremiah’s Take: In the Poconos, booking momentum matters. A manager who can’t keep your calendar full through slow spring months (March–May) will cost you in June.

Choose the Manager First, Then the Property

We tell buyers this all the time: the property doesn’t perform on its own.

If you pick a property manager who:

• Is local and compliance-minded

• Has quality control over cleaning and maintenance

• Can optimize your calendar year-round

  
  

You’ll make more money and sleep at night.

At Investment Real Estate of the Poconos, we help buyers vet property managers before they close, and connect them with Galvanized Management if they want a full in-house operation.

Key Takeaways

• Vet your manager’s compliance knowledge, not just their fee

• Make sure they have in-house teams who can handle snow, trash, and inspections

• Ask about township coverage: Tobyhanna, Coolbaugh, Middle Smithfield, Tunkhannock, and Pocono all have different rules

• A good manager pays for themselves in permit protection, better reviews, and higher occupancy

---

FAQ: Vetting a Poconos Property Manager Before Buying an Airbnb

Why should I vet a property manager before I buy a Poconos Airbnb? 

Because the wrong manager can delay your permit, hurt your reviews, and cost you thousands in lost bookings. Monroe County’s Airbnb rules are township-specific and strict. A manager who isn’t local or compliance-minded may not get you permitted on time, or at all.

What makes a property manager “local enough” for the Poconos? 

Look for managers who:

• Have an office within 30–45 minutes of your property

• Actively manage homes in your target township (Tobyhanna, Coolbaugh, Kidder, Tunkhannock, Penn Forest)

• Can respond same-day to snow, lockouts, or septic emergencies

  
  

Remote or statewide managers often fail township inspections because they don’t understand local permit requirements. We also own Galvanized Management and our entire team is local.

Should my property manager handle Airbnb permitting? 

Yes. Airbnb permits in Monroe County do not transfer automatically when a home sells. Ask your manager:

• Will you manage the township permit application and inspections?

• Do you track HOA and township regulation changes?

• Will you handle renewals each year?

  
  

A manager who doesn’t do this will leave you scrambling and could delay your ability to legally operate.

What questions should I ask about cleaning and maintenance? 

• Do you use in-house cleaning teams or subcontractors?

• How do you check quality and prevent missed turnovers?

• Can you handle trash, snow, and septic emergencies?

  
  

Bad reviews in the Poconos are almost always tied to cleaning and maintenance. You need a manager who can be on-site quickly.

What hidden fees should I look out for in Airbnb management contracts? 

Many “cheap” managers (20% or less) add:

• Vendor markups

• Cleaning coordination charges

• Snow, trash, and lawn fees

• Emergency callout charges

  
  

A 25% all-inclusive manager may be more cost-effective than a lower-fee manager who nickel-and-dimes you.

How do I know if a manager can keep my Airbnb booked? 

Ask about their:

• Airbnb ratings across their portfolio

• Use of dynamic pricing tools

• Average occupancy through slow spring months (March–May)

  
  

In the Poconos, booking momentum matters. A weak manager will hurt your calendar and reduce visibility on Airbnb.

Can Investment Real Estate of the Poconos help me find the right manager before I buy? 

Yes. We guide buyers through manager vetting before they close and connect them with Galvanized Management if they want a full in-house operation. Choosing the manager first protects your permit, your reviews, and your net ROI.

---

About the Author

Jeremiah Noll is a Poconos-based broker (License #RM425834) and rental operator who runs Galvanized Management and iREPoconos. He helps owners and investors make smarter decisions by focusing on what actually happens after the purchase: rules, costs, operations, and performance.

---

Reviews & Testimonials

What owners and investors are saying about working with Investment Real Estate of the Poconos, from the first deal to the realities of long-term ownership. Read More Reviews

"When a great investment property hit the market, and I live 2 hours away, no problem! Jeremiah was on it immediately, doing a video walkthrough and submitting an offer that same day, landing me a fantastic deal. This is the kind of company you want on your team for every type of property investment need."

- Lisa Randolph, View on google